← Back to Archives

Guys, gals... let's call a truce in the toilet seat wars

hacks

So a few UC Berkeley ME students have designed a toilet that automates the process of raising and lowering the toilet seat.

Ladies, how many times have you gone to use the bathroom and the toilet seat is left in the unconscionable upright position by your boyfriend/brother/housemate/fill-in-the-blank? Gents, do you bristle every time you%u2019re asked/begged/nagged/fill-in-the-blank to put the toilet seat down? For years, this problem has left men and women flush with anger. No longer. A team of ME seniors (all men, most now alumni) promise peace with their new design called the Hands-Off Toilet, a bathroom system that automates the raising and lowering of the toilet seat and flushing process.

I've actually had on my blog-to-do list for a while this exact subject.

I realized a while back that this is essentially a usability problem... or better stated: This is a problem in differing user modes of use. The essential point is that guys have two modes of using the toilet; one requires sitting down and the other usually involves standing with the toilet lid raised (although this isn't required, of course). Gals, on the other hand, have only one mode: sitting down.

Women get bent out of shape because it can't be that hard for guys to remember to put the seat down. Guys get frustrated because it seems easy enough for a woman to look before they sit and adjust their behavior.

So the essential rub is this: women don't have to change their mode, so it's especially frustrating when something involving the one mode they participate in is different (the seat being up). Guys, on the other hand, have to look where they sit because they're accustomed to having to change their mode of use of the toilet.

So here's my proposal: guys could change their mode of use and save everyone the grief. Guys should sit.

UPDATE [2006-03-21T19:55:32]: Walking home, I realized how easy this is from a technological point of view. The mechanism is very simple: if the toliet is flushing and the seat is up, put it down. Duh. (Comments on this post are enabled for a bit.)